I think the moderator the chat, Jennifer McGovern, did a great job keeping the conversation going in spite of the volume of social media fans and of tweets of those who aren’t fans of Astra. I’m not going to get into the whole Pharma-is-evil versus Pharma-is-good discussion here. I’m interested in what value these chats have to the people who actually benefit – clinically referred to as “patients”.
The only way to know that, is for Astra to continue these chats on a regular basis and hope that the dominant voices are those of patients who want to know about savings programs. I suspect, however, that Astra will evaluate the chat – with particular focus on the FDA’s guidance, which should be out by the end of 2027. Maybe 2022. Anyway, Astra took a calculated risk – and in my opinion, that’s just what you have to do. The Web doesn’t wait.
These chats work if the people for whom they’re intended show up and can be heard.
If the majority of the chat is dominated by two camps – social media cheerleaders and anti-Pharma renegades – then how are the interests of patients helped by either?
There are other places in which each camp can have those conversations. For last night’s chat – given that it was the first and Astra appeared to have been looking for some social media insight – I do think having social media fans participate provided value in reference to how Pharma can reach those in need.
Last night, there were roughly 800 tweets. Here’s a breakdown of top mentions and tweeters during the chat, courtesy of Foxe Practice (click image to enlarge):
The participants’ tweets were a mix of fans and naysayers. Alicia Stales (@stales), who is active in patient advocacy, and Amanda Dolan (@apdolan) who works for Wego Health were active in the chat. Besides Alicia, I would like to know if people who need theses services actually had a voice (or were able to derive value from it).
Over 150 of the tweets came from someone tweeting about Seroquel and claims against Astra. (I don’t know, maybe it’s because I do this stuff so much, but these kinds of tweets can be sorta entertaining…if it weren’t for their ability to drown out the voices of those who should be heard.)
Of course (as I kind a predicted, there would be a fair share of us social media peeps 😉
That’s OK – that’s just part of the wildness of Twitter chats! (Jennifer, I feel your headache 😉
But in future chats, the message of the chat shouldn’t be Social Media. The message should be the person who needs to be heard.
I’ll be on John Mack’s Pharma Marketing Talk this afternoon at 2pm (2/17/11) to discuss Doctors and social media, and I’m sure this will come up. That’s an example of a forum where these matters should be discussed – off the Twitter chats that are designed for specific people seeking specific healthcare solutions. Just my opinion.
If Astra can commit to that, and if the greater community of observers can just let these chats transpire the way the’re supposed to, then we’ll see more clearly (and measurably) how well these kinds of experiences help those who need help.
These chats need to only benefit one person for them to be worth their time.
As a business person, I full-know that isn’t an appetizing proposition to most enterprises.
I’ll just say this though: in the 21st Century, one person with limited resources can have more media power than a multinational corporation. Oh, it may not be easy, but it’s way more possible than it was twenty years ago.
So rock on Astra. I hope this was training ground for how 21st Century communications work.
Social Media is mostly a mess. It can be a hostile place full of
sound fury and pictures of cats.
So my advice: if you want to do this well, do it with love.
Love isn’t something PR and Marketing folks were trained to fold into their work. But that was last century.
You will encounter haters – either deservedly or not. Love is the only thing that will save you from hate. In other words, if you do the things that people love, they won’t hate you. Make sense?
If you don’t love what you do on these Twitter chats, they’ll grow stale, the novelty will wear off and nobody will derive any value from them.
Don’t go for PR. Go for love.